Philosophical Bunk in the New York Times

Philosophical Bunk in the New York Times

Le penseur de RodinIn fighting the antis, we often get hung up on issues particular to gun rights: magazine capacity or universal background checks or open carry, for example. Those have to be contested in detail, but the great struggle for us is about the balance between the individual and the state. It's a cliché, but one that is based on truth: gun control is not about guns, it's about control.

"The Stone" is a New York Times feature the paper describes as "a forum for contemporary philosophers and other thinkers on issues both timely and timeless." A lot of its contributors are not going to make you forget Plato or Schopenauer, but a little philosophy is good, even if the title (the "philosopher's stone," get it?) is too cute by half.

A recent column by John Terrell, Regenstein Curator of Pacific Anthropology at the Field Museum of Natural History and professor of anthropology at the University of Illinois in Chicago, nicely illustrates what we are up against at the very basic level.

Terrell argues that "The sanctification of the rights of individuals and their liberties today by libertarians and Tea Party conservatives is contrary to our evolved human nature as social animals." He adds that "The basic unit of human social life is not and never has been the selfish and self-serving individual."


If you are, like most SGN readers, a libertarian or conservative or both, you may be surprised to find that you are just a big meanie who doesn't care about other people, and unevolved, to boot. Watch those knuckles!


Well, examples to disprove that thesis are almost infinite. Were faculty-lounge pinks the ones getting Ebola from treating suffering Liberians? Nope, those were various Christian missionaries, none of them Unitarians, so far as I could see. It is well-established that conservatives give vastly more, both in funds and in volunteer time, to charities than do liberals. The funds that private and religious charities distribute abroad vastly exceed government foreign aid.

Prof. Terrell, like most on the left, identifies "society" and the state. The state is the agent for any positive change to be made in people's lives. To oppose the state is to be selfish and self-serving. To "sanctify" rights and liberties is to accept a myth that tends to limit the great good the state can do.

To us, the state and society are not one and the same. Social goods are spread by a variety of institutions: the church, private educational organizations, fraternal groups and most importantly, the family. The state is a necessary evil, essential for protecting the border, building dams and making sure there are no rats in our Spam, but otherwise is a dangerous entity inclined toward tyranny that requires uninterrupted watching. Balancing its power requires an active, well-armed populace that is jealous of its rights.

It is not an accident that the academic left has been the implacable opponent of the church, private enterprise, groups like the Boy Scouts, and the family, which they deride as a patriarchal arrangement built only to oppress women, children and sexual minorities. Suppressing any institution that mediates between the individual and the state has been the game plan of every would-be tyrant from Kim Jong-Un to Hugo Chavez, and the goal is always the same: to leave the state completely unchallenged and the individual alone.


When Hitler suppressed the Boy Scouts in favor of the Hitler Youth, he showed that no values other than National Socialist values would be tolerated. He made clear to his inner circle that when he was through with the Jews, he'd deal with the church. No tyrant can accept "society" that is separate from the state.

Americans are quite capable of forming our own organizations and banding together for collective action without prejudicing their individual rights and without direction from above. That challenges the belief system of Prof. Terrell and his kind, which is why any sort of gun owner activism is always characterized as a plot by the gun industry rather than grassroots Americans in action.

Owning and practicing with a gun is the very opposite of selfish and self-serving. When hundreds of millions are armed and prepared, no would-be dictator can sleep well. It is an example of individuals voluntarily banding together to preserve the rights of everyone. That's what we call society!


Students Suspended for Photos with Airsoft Guns

Two students at Bristol-Plymouth Regional Technical School in Taunton, Mass., were suspended for posing with airsoft guns in one of their own homes.

Read here for the full story.

Luxury Gun Clubs Becoming More Popular

"Guntry clubs," or luxurious shooting facilities offering the same sort of amenities one would find at a golf course: comfy lounges, food and drink, pro shop, locker rooms, professional instruction, etc., are becoming much more popular. Is this good or bad for the shooting community?

Read here for more.

Young Girl Loses Control of an Uzi, Kills Firearms Instructor

A Lake Havasu City, Ariz., firearms instructor was killed when a nine-year-old girl lost control of an Uzi submachine gun and a bullet hit him in the head. How young is too young when it comes to automatic firearms?

Read here for the full story of the incident.

Guns & Pot: An Uneasy Combo

Is there any overlap between gun owners and those in favor of legalizing marijuana?

Check out the full story here.

New House Bill Targets SMG-Toting Bureaucrats

Rep. Chris Stewart (R-Utah) has introduced the Regulatory Agency De-militarization (RAD) Act, a bill intended to force agencies not involved in law enforcement as that term is generally understood to disband their police forces. Do non-law enforcement agencies such as the USDA really need automatic firearms?

Read the full story here.

Only the Polarized Are Actually Polarized?

Are politics too polarized, or is polarization what you get when people actually believe in something?

Read here for more.

Why You Can't Always Trust the Police

A police scandal in the British city of Rotherham, where a gang abused more than 1,400 girls while authorities looked the other way, illustrates why you can't rely solely on the police for your protection.

Read here for the full story.

The Straight Dope on Kalashnikov Sanctions

Kalashnikov Concern products have been banned from further importation into the U.S. as part of sanctions against Russia for its actions in Ukraine. What do the new sanctions mean for gun owners?

Read here for the full story.

Smart Guns: What the Antis Won't Admit

A California gun store that had planned to offer pistols with so-called "smart gun" technology scrapped the idea after receiving backlash from gun owners.

Read the full account here.

Anti-Gun Initiative 594 Passes in Washington

While the November 4 election was somewhat of a victory for gun owners with (mostly) pro-gun Republicans gaining seats in the Senate and the House, anti-gunners have scored a big win in Washington. What does this new initiative mean for gun owners in the Evergreen State?

Read here for the full story.

Open Carry Protests: Our Internal Dilemma

Open Carry Texas (OCT), a group campaigning for gun rights in Texas, has stirred controversy among pro-gun groups such as the NRA and left the issue of open carrying of rifles up for debate. Where do we draw the line on what is reasonable in terms of achieving political goals?

Check out the full story here.

The Scourge of Toy Guns

A New York professor says the cure for police shooting people with toy guns is to boycott toy guns. Is that the answer?

Read the story here.

Wolverines? Michigan Nixes American Sniper

The University of Michigan temporarily cancelled a scheduled viewing of the film American Sniper following criticism from some of the school's Muslim students.

Get the full story here.

Front-Yard Pistol Range: Bad Idea

A Florida man built a gun range in his front yard with an impromptu dirt backstop, which would be fine if he lived in a rural area. That simply wasn't the case.

Read the whole story here.

Pot Clubs Fund San Francisco Gun Buyback

In what was inevitably dubbed a "joint effort," San Francisco police conducted a gun buyback funded by local marijuana dispensaries.

Find out more here.

Maryland Stockpiles Pistol Brass: To What End?

For the past 15 years, every pistol sold in the state of Maryland has had to come with a fired case that is submitted to the state's registry of fired pistol brass for reference. Now the state is running out of warehouse space to store the cases.

Find out more here.

Legislator Wants to Ban Silhouette Targets

A Pennsylvania legislator wants to ban the use of silhouette targets on shooting ranges in the state.

Check out the full story here.

Campus Concealed Carry: The Toga Party Fallacy

The group Students for Concealed Carry is making increasingly stronger pushes to allow law-abiding citizens to carry concealed on college campuses. Unfortunately, some still hold the mistaken belief that all college students are wildly irresponsible.

Find out more here.

Feds Consider Gun Show Spying

The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) took the side of gun owners after it was uncovered that the Drug Enforcement Agency (DEA) had recently considered spying on gun shows.

Get the full story here.

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Springfield Hellcat OSP Review

Springfield Hellcat OSP Review

Patrick Sweeney takes the Springfield Hellcat OSP to the range to test it out!

Hornady Kestrel 5700 Ballistics Weather Meter with Hornady 4DOF

Hornady Kestrel 5700 Ballistics Weather Meter with Hornady 4DOF

The Hornady Kestrel 5700 combines complete onsite environmental measurements with Hornady 4DOF trajectory solutions.

See More Popular Videos

Trending Articles

Virginia Republican Rep. Glenn Davis introduced two pro-2A measures in a special session that are designed to partially roll back some restrictive laws. 2nd Amendment

Fighting Back in Virginia

Mark Chesnut - August 24, 2020

Virginia Republican Rep. Glenn Davis introduced two pro-2A measures in a special session that...

One New York lawmaker is pushing legislation to bypass the Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms Act (PLCAA) and allow gunmakers to be sued if their lawfully made products are used for criminal purposes. 2nd Amendment

New York Targeting Gunmakers Instead of Criminals

Mark Chesnut - August 19, 2020

One New York lawmaker is pushing legislation to bypass the Protection of Lawful Commerce in...

The Leupold VX-Freedom AR scope line hits the sweet spot on frills, performance and cost to you. Optics

Leupold VX-Freedom AR Scopes

Jim Angell - August 18, 2020

The Leupold VX-Freedom AR scope line hits the sweet spot on frills, performance and cost to...

While Germany is the Edenic home of modern sniping, they were always one step behind the Soviets during World War II, despite fielding some excellent sniper rifles. Rifles

German Sniper Rifles of World War I and II

David M. Fortier - August 13, 2020

While Germany is the Edenic home of modern sniping, they were always one step behind the...

See More Trending Articles

More 2nd Amendment

The Fifth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has unanimously ruled that New Jersey Attorney General Gurbir Grewal is “subject to the jurisdiction of Texas courts” in a First Amendment case brought by Defense Distributed, a Texas-based firm, and the Second Amendment Foundation. 2nd Amendment

SAF, Defense Distributed Win Court Victory in 3D Gun Case

Second Amendment Foundation - August 22, 2020

The Fifth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has unanimously ruled that New Jersey Attorney General...

With many having to evacuate and possibly never see their homes and belongings again, some Oregon homeowners are protecting their property from looters. 2nd Amendment

Armed Oregon Homeowners Protecting Their Property

Clay Bell - September 18, 2020

With many having to evacuate and possibly never see their homes and belongings again, some...

Lawrence Keane, senior vice president and general counsel for the National Shooting Sports Foundation (NSSF), said in a Wednesday op-ed that, “New York's gun control Utopia is living hell.” 2nd Amendment

NSSF General Counsel Calls NYC Gun Violence 'A Living Hell'

Mark Chesnut - September 11, 2020

Lawrence Keane, senior vice president and general counsel for the National Shooting Sports...

17-year-old Kyle Rittenhouse was armed with an AR-15 and was guarding a car lot in Kenosha near where protests were occurring. When protesters, after verbally abusing him, began trying to burn some of the cars, Rittenhouse apparently tried to stop them. 2nd Amendment

Violent Felon Rioters Shot – Kyle Rittenhouse Defends Himself in Kenosha, WI

Clay Bell - August 27, 2020

17-year-old Kyle Rittenhouse was armed with an AR-15 and was guarding a car lot in Kenosha...

See More 2nd Amendment

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW OUR CURRENT ISSUE

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Get Digital Access.

All Firearms News subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now