Bandemonium in the 3rd Circuit: No Mags Over 10 Rounds

Bandemonium in the 3rd Circuit: No Mags Over 10 Rounds
(Photo courtesy of Shutterstock)

Only a few weeks after a three-judge panel of the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals declared California’s ban on gun magazines that hold more than 10 rounds unconstitutional, the a three-judge panel of the 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals has deemed a similar ban in New Jersey to be permitted under the Second Amendment.

This is the second time that the 3rd Circuit has ruled in favor of the ban, and this time it came in the case Association of New Jersey Rifle and Pistol Clubs v. Attorney General of New Jersey.

In its ruling, the court concluded that such a ban, “does not burden the core Second Amendment guarantee, for five reasons: (1) it does not categorically ban a class of firearms but is rather a ban on a subset of magazines; (2) it is not a prohibition of a class of arms overwhelmingly chosen by Americans for self-defense in the home; (3) it does not disarm or substantially affect Americans’ ability to defend themselves; (4) New Jersey residents can still possess and use magazines, just with fewer rounds; and (5) it cannot be the case that possession of a firearm in the home for self-defense is a protected form of possession under all circumstances. By this rationale, any type of firearm possessed in the home would be protected merely because it could be used for self-defense.”

Unfortunately, the true meaning of the Second Amendment isn’t ever addressed in the decision, that being the right to own the same arms as the military to defend oneself from a tyrannical government. Instead, the court chose to nitpick around the fringes of the issue on whether normal-capacity magazines that come standard with many firearms can legally be owned by New Jersey residents.


The two judges choosing to uphold the law were Judge Kent A. Jordan and Judge Jan Richards Roth. Jordan was nominated to the court in 2006 by President George W. Bush. Roth was nominated to the court in 1991 by President George H. W. Bush.


For his part, Judge Paul Matey, the newest member of the court nominated by President Donald Trump just last year, wrote in dissent that “the record does not show the State reasonably tailored the regulation to serve its interest in public safety without burdening more conduct than reasonably necessary. First, the State rests on the ambiguous argument that ‘when LCM equipped firearms are used, more bullets are fired, more victims are shot, and more people are killed than in other gun attacks.’ … Perhaps, but this still begs the question of whether a 10-round limit on magazine capacity will affect the outcomes of enough gun attacks to measurably reduce gun injuries and death.”

Interestingly, Judge Kenneth Lee wrote of the recent 9th Circuit decision, “California’s near-categorical ban of LCMs strikes at the core of the Second Amendment—the right to armed self-defense. Armed self-defense is a fundamental right rooted in tradition and the text of the Second Amendment. Indeed, from pre-colonial times to today’s post-modern era, the right to defend hearth and home has remained paramount. California’s law imposes a substantial burden on this right to self-defense.”

Freelance writer and editor Mark Chesnut is the owner/editorial director at Red Setter Communications LLC. An avid hunter, shooter and political observer, he has been covering Second Amendment issues and politics on a near-daily basis for the past 20 years.

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Springfield Hellcat OSP Review

Springfield Hellcat OSP Review

Patrick Sweeney takes the Springfield Hellcat OSP to the range to test it out!

Shooting the 20mm Lahti

Shooting the 20mm Lahti

David Fortier had the chance to fire the Lahti L-39 while filming the 2018 season of Guns&AmmoTV while on location at DriveTanks.com.

See More Popular Videos

Trending Articles

This article will walk you through the process of building a Glock pistol from an 80 percent frame. Gunsmithing

How To Build a Glock From an 80 Percent Frame

Gus Norcross - August 13, 2020

This article will walk you through the process of building a Glock pistol from an 80 percent...

The Wilson Combat-SIG Sauer WCP320 pistol is now legal for IDPA Stock Service Pistol Class Competition and USPSA Production/Carry Optics Classifications. Handguns

WCP320 Pistol Now Legal for IDPA and USPSA

Firearms News Staff - August 14, 2020

The Wilson Combat-SIG Sauer WCP320 pistol is now legal for IDPA Stock Service Pistol Class...

Mark and Patricia McCloskey, the targets of an unwarranted prosecution by an overzealous Soros-backed St. Louis prosecutor, are slated to speak at next week's Republican National Convention. 2nd Amendment

McCloskey's In the Limelight: Speaking at Next Week's RNC

Mark Chesnut - August 21, 2020

Mark and Patricia McCloskey, the targets of an unwarranted prosecution by an overzealous...

We go behind closed doors at the factory to see how SIG Sauer's ammo is developed and manufactured! Ammo

SIG Sauer Ammunition — How Good Is It?

Tom Beckstrand - August 20, 2020

We go behind closed doors at the factory to see how SIG Sauer's ammo is developed and...

See More Trending Articles

More 2nd Amendment

Governor Mike DeWine's STRONG Ohio anti-gun bill is facing strong, unified opposition. 2nd Amendment

Opposition to 'STRONG Ohio' Remains Strong

Buckeye Firearms Association - August 24, 2020

Governor Mike DeWine's STRONG Ohio anti-gun bill is facing strong, unified opposition.

Lawrence Keane, senior vice president and general counsel for the National Shooting Sports Foundation (NSSF), said in a Wednesday op-ed that, “New York's gun control Utopia is living hell.” 2nd Amendment

NSSF General Counsel Calls NYC Gun Violence 'A Living Hell'

Mark Chesnut - September 11, 2020

Lawrence Keane, senior vice president and general counsel for the National Shooting Sports...

By now you've undoubtedly heard about the lawsuit filed by the New York Attorney General against the NRA, but you might be wondering what's really going on. Industry

The Tragic Mess That is Today's NRA

Jeff Knox - September 21, 2020

By now you've undoubtedly heard about the lawsuit filed by the New York Attorney General...

While Mark and Patricia McCloskey had some important things to say in their Republican National Convention speech on Monday night, a more interesting story is all the hatred they received from rabid anti-gunners. 2nd Amendment

The Left's Incredible Hatred of the McCloskeys

Mark Chesnut - August 26, 2020

While Mark and Patricia McCloskey had some important things to say in their Republican...

See More 2nd Amendment

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW OUR CURRENT ISSUE

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Get Digital Access.

All Firearms News subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now