Here's Why We Don't Trust Research

Here's Why We Don't Trust Research

Anti-gunners always lambaste gun owners for opposing government-funded research on gun control issues. That opposition is founded on intimate knowledge of the sort of pseudo-science that emerged when the government supported research in the past, and got a pretty big boost from this recent scandal (tip of the hat to SGN contributor Clayton E. Cramer for discovering it).

A Columbia University professor and a graduate student from UCLA teamed up to design a little social experiment in which they hired a group of canvassers from the Los Angeles LGBT Center to go door-to-door in neighborhoods that voted for Proposition 8, a measure that briefly, but unsuccessfully, banned gay marriage in California. For those who have restricted their reading entirely to gun magazines for a decade or so, LGBT stands for lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgendered. Sometimes a Q is added at the end for "queer."

The canvassers followed standardized scripts meant to convince those voters to change their minds through non-confrontational, one-on-one contact. The thinking was that if these benighted souls had actual contact with those who choose an alternate lifestyle, their opinions might change. Some canvassers made clear their own sexual identity, others did not, and the study compared results achieved when they were open about it or made no mention.

Well, to make a long story short, follow-up surveys seemed to show that doorway conversations with canvassers who openly identified as LGBT led to measurable changes in attitudes among those surveyed. The research was published in Science magazine to approval all around. Happy ending, right?


Not so fast. A pair of Berkeley researchers tried to replicate the results online and their findings didn't jibe. They informed Columbia professor Donald Green, who asked the UCLA grad student, Michael LeCour, for a peek at the raw data. The latter's answer was pretty much "the dog ate my homework."


After some investigation, Green came to what must have been a painful conclusion: "There was no data, and no plausible way of getting the data." It appears that canvassers talked to people in the Proposition 8-supporting neighborhoods, but the crucial follow-up surveys were never sent.


Covering the scandal in the New Yorker, Maria Konnikova wrote:

"There's another issue at play: the nature of belief. As I've written before, we are far quicker to believe things that mesh with our view of how life should be. Green is a firm supporter of gay marriage, and that may have made him especially pleased about the study. Did it have a similar effect on liberally minded reviewers at Science? We know that studies confirming liberal thinking sometimes get a pass where ones challenging those ideas might get killed in review; the same effect may have made journalists more excited about covering the results."

Um, yeah. And that's why gun owners are justifiably skeptical of research conducted by people who are politically vested in a particular outcome. If research could be conducted by little green men from Mars, maybe. Conducted by academics steeped in the left-wing ethos that reigns on campus today, not so much.


After all, it was our own Clayton Cramer whose research debunked Michael Bellesiles' Arming America, an award-winning book that purported to show that early Americans really didn't own all that many guns. His problem was that he hadn't read the primary sources and Cramer had. The dog ate his homework, too.

We are starting to see a lot of ends-justify-the-means thinking in what is supposed to be the cool, appraising world of research. On topics like global warming, there is an orthodoxy that verges on censorship that Galileo would recognize. Keeping ambitious academics out of the gun world is a vital piece of work for us.


Recommended for You

Many of the concepts pioneered by Hobart are seen in modern armies across the world and the AVRE platform is alive and well. Historical

Hobarts Funnies and the Battle for the Scheldt

Neal S Shera - July 15, 2019

Many of the concepts pioneered by Hobart are seen in modern armies across the world and the...

Please sign and share the petition to get the required 100,000 signatures by July 27. 2nd Amendment

Tell the White House that the 2nd Amendment Was Not Given to the People by Government

Firearms News - July 02, 2019

Please sign and share the petition to get the required 100,000 signatures by July 27.

The last of Germany's infamous Elefant tank destroyers. Historical

World War II German Elefant Tank Destroyers

Neal S Shera - July 12, 2019

The last of Germany's infamous Elefant tank destroyers.

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Springfield Armory Saint Victor in .308

Springfield Armory Saint Victor in .308

The Saint Victor in .308 features a 16" light weight barrel, M-Lok® free float hand guard and included flip-up sights.

M134 Mini-Gun

M134 Mini-Gun

While filming the 2018 season of Guns&AmmoTV we had the unique opportunity to fire the M134 Minigun.

The GPO Rangeguide 10x50

The GPO Rangeguide 10x50

If you need to see your game, and know the distance in all hunting environments, the GPO RANGEGUIDE 10×50 is your winning ticket.

See more Popular Videos

Trending Stories

Rhode Islanders are setting brushfires for freedom once again as they advance a Second Amendment Sanctuary Town movement. 2nd Amendment

SPECIAL REPORT: BIG 2A HISTORY BEING MADE IN LITTLE RHODE ISLAND

John Peterson - May 22, 2019

Rhode Islanders are setting brushfires for freedom once again as they advance a Second...

A $50 Ring Loc-Kit gives AirForce Condor airgunners unparalleled power and accuracy. Air Guns

AirForce Airguns Condor Ring-Loc Kit Review

Tom Gaylord - May 29, 2019

A $50 Ring Loc-Kit gives AirForce Condor airgunners unparalleled power and accuracy.

Governor Northam is calling a special session of the General Assembly on Tuesday, July 9th, to do nothing but pass more gun control! 2nd Amendment

Virginia Governor Northam Declares War on Gun Owners

Virginia Citizens Defense League - July 09, 2019

Governor Northam is calling a special session of the General Assembly on Tuesday, July 9th, to...

See More Stories

More Industry

An arrest was made following a cell phone being thrown on stage as President Trump prepared to address the NRA Annual Meetings and Lt. Col. Oliver North was ousted as the NRA President. Industry

Controversy Rocks the NRA and Day Two in Indy

Lynn Burkhead, OSG Senior Digital Editor - April 27, 2019

An arrest was made following a cell phone being thrown on stage as President Trump prepared to...

Berger Bullets is now shipping the new 6.5mm 156gr EOL Elite Hunter projectiles to exclusive retailers. Ammo

Berger 6.5mm 156gr EOL Elite Hunter Bullets Available Now

Berger Bullets - July 10, 2019

Berger Bullets is now shipping the new 6.5mm 156gr EOL Elite Hunter projectiles to exclusive...

The HKPDW Pistol Stabilizing Brace is 3-position adjustable and compatible with the MP5 and MP5K Reverse Stretch clones. Accessories

SB Tactical HKPDW Adjustable Pistol Stabilizing Brace

SB Tactical - July 25, 2019

The HKPDW Pistol Stabilizing Brace is 3-position adjustable and compatible with the MP5 and...

See More Industry

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Temporary Price Reduction.

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW OUR CURRENT ISSUE

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

×