Home Defense Shotgun – Good Idea or Not?

There are pros and cons to everything, and this is especially true with the 12 gauge shotgun as a home defense gun.

Home Defense Shotgun – Good Idea or Not?
Like any firearm the 12 gauge shotgun has certain strengths and weaknesses you need to be aware of before choosing it to protect your home. Photo by Sean Utley.

If you are considering a 12 gauge shotgun for defending your home, there are certain things you should be aware of. Chiefly you need to know what the pros and cons are of employing a shotgun for home defense. As with anything, the 12 gauge shotgun has a number of attributes which make it very well suited for personal protection, and others which detract from it in this role. What follows will be an examination of both the good and the bad of the 12 gauge.

Pros

One of the good points of a 12 gauge shotgun is they tend to be affordable. You can purchase a used pump shotgun at a very economical price. So this puts them well within reach of your average blue collar worker. Plus, they are readily available and easy to find. A simple mundane short barrel 12 gauge pump-action shotgun is all you need. You don’t need to get very fancy.

There is a certain intimidation factor to the 12 gauge, which other firearms lack. Part of this has to do with the large bore-size, and part of its reputation as a fight-stopper. Often simply presenting a firearm will stop a crime from progressing, and nothing is as intimidating as looking down the bore of a 12 gauge. No one ever looked at the wrong end of a 12 gauge and said, "I can take that hit."

Of course you should never rely on the intimidation factor of a firearm to protect you. You need to be ready and willing to use it. If you should need to protect you or your family, the great virtue of the 12 gauge shotgun is its terminal performance. When loaded with 2 ¾-inch slugs, 00 or No. 1 buckshot the 12 gauge is brutally effective at short range, such as is encountered in a typical indoor defensive shooting scenario. One well-placed shot is usually a fight stopper.


Shotgun-Protection
You do not need expensive or fancy ammunition, any low recoil 2 ¾-inch 00 or No. 1 buckshot will suffice for protecting you and your family. Photo courtesy Hornady.

Plus, you do not need to get fancy about load selection. You do not need expensive Gucci loads for protecting your family inside your home. Any run of the mill 2 ¾-inch 00 buck, No. 1 buck or slug load will suffice. You do not need special plated pellets, shot buffer or fancy wads. We are talking about distances measured in feet, not yards. At these distances, pattern size does not matter. It doesn’t even come into play. If you live in a residential area with neighbors, then you should stick with buckshot rather than slugs due to problems with over-penetration.


In our litigation happy society the mundane 12 gauge shotgun has another virtue, it is relatively low profile. It is not an “assault weapon,” and it doesn’t even resemble one. So, your DA probably will not see a PR opportunity if you are involved in defensive shooting protecting your family.

Lastly, when not leaning in the corner a 12 gauge can perform double-duty as a hunting gun, or for recreational shooting. It is not limited to only defensive use. A 12 gauge can be used for small game hunting, bird hunting, medium-size game hunting and can be used to protect your family from even the big bears. It is a very versatile firearm.

Cons

While the 12 gauge does have a number of good characteristics, it also has some real fleas. This is especially true if a smaller stature member of the family might have to employ it. The most obvious negative attribute of the 12 gauge shotgun is its recoil. Even when firing “low recoil” defensive loads, it still has a healthy kick. This may dissuade certain members of the family from wanting to practice with it. Remember, you need to practice with and try to master any firearm you expect to use to protect your life with. The heavy recoil also slows follow-up shots.

Another negative is the 12 gauge’s limited ammunition capacity. Five to eight shots is all you get. When it comes to ammunition in a gunfight, more is always better. Worst still, they are slow to reload. This is especially true in the dark when your stress is through the roof and you are experiencing a major adrenalin dump. You must train to get good at quickly reloading a shotgun.


Overall length is also an issue. Even a regular 18-inch barrel "riot" gun is still most of three feet long. This can be a problem inside a house, especially if you are trying to juggle a cell phone while calling the police. Shorter is typically better. Then there is the issue of the safety which (except for Mossberg) are typically push-buttons set up for a right-handed shooter. This is something to consider if you or someone in your family is left-handed.

Shotgun-Protection
A look at the pattern from one round of Winchester’s Super-X 16 pellet No. 1 buck at 15 feet. You still have to aim a shotgun, but terminal performance is impressive if you connect.

Then there is the old wives’ tale that you cannot miss with a shotgun. At the distances encountered in your home the shot pattern will be very small. You need to aim a shotgun or you can easily miss your target. If you do miss your target slugs and buckshot can shoot through a wall. So you need to be aware of what is behind your target. If you live alone, in the boonies, then this will not be a problem. Otherwise, it’s something you will need to consider.

In the end the 12 gauge shotgun has a number of good and bad qualities when it comes to defensive use inside a home. You need to weigh all of them when making your decision. Once you have, simply decide what is best for you.


GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Firearms News Takes a Look at the Aero Precision 7.5-Inch AR Pistol Upper In 5.56

Firearms News Takes a Look at the Aero Precision 7.5-Inch AR Pistol Upper In 5.56

Vincent DeNiro, editor of Firearms News, does some shooting with the Aero Precision Atlas S-One 7.5-Inch AR pistol upper in 5.56.

Promo: Firearms News September 2019 – Issue #18! THE BIG MSR HUNTING ISSUE!

Promo: Firearms News September 2019 – Issue #18! THE BIG MSR HUNTING ISSUE!

Pick up a copy at your local magazine stand, Walmart, Barnes & Noble, or major book retailer!

Hornady Kestrel 5700 Ballistics Weather Meter with Hornady 4DOF

Hornady Kestrel 5700 Ballistics Weather Meter with Hornady 4DOF

The Hornady Kestrel 5700 combines complete onsite environmental measurements with Hornady 4DOF trajectory solutions.

Preview: Firearms News May 2019 Issue 10

Preview: Firearms News May 2019 Issue 10

Rikk Rambo penned over 16,000 words of excitement covering two great handguns from Smith & Wesson! The S&W Performance Center .500 10-inch revolver and the S&W Performance Center .44 Magnum with 3 5/8- inch barrel!

See More Popular Videos

Trending Articles

If you want to keep the peace, keep and bear arms. Don't give up your guns. Any other choice would be ridiculous. 2nd Amendment

Is Red Dawn Really Just Ridiculous? If Not, Who Would Citizen Disarmament Help?

David Codrea - May 29, 2019

If you want to keep the peace, keep and bear arms. Don't give up your guns. Any other choice...

This will be the first of many investigative reports about the NRA by Firearms News. 2nd Amendment

Firearms News Investigates the NRA: Part 1

Nedd Scott - July 18, 2019

This will be the first of many investigative reports about the NRA by Firearms News.

A $50 Ring Loc-Kit gives AirForce Condor airgunners unparalleled power and accuracy. Air Guns

AirForce Airguns Condor Ring-Loc Kit Review

Tom Gaylord - May 29, 2019

A $50 Ring Loc-Kit gives AirForce Condor airgunners unparalleled power and accuracy.

Rhode Islanders are setting brushfires for freedom once again as they advance a Second Amendment Sanctuary Town movement. 2nd Amendment

SPECIAL REPORT: BIG 2A HISTORY BEING MADE IN LITTLE RHODE ISLAND

John Peterson - May 22, 2019

Rhode Islanders are setting brushfires for freedom once again as they advance a Second...

See More Trending Articles

More Personal Defense

The holy combination of the HK VP9, the Gemtech GM9, and the Surefire X400 Ultra is what sits in Will Dabbs' bedside table. Personal Defense

Building the Best Handgun for Home Defense

Will Dabbs, MD - April 24, 2018

The holy combination of the HK VP9, the Gemtech GM9, and the Surefire X400 Ultra is what sits...

Drills for beyond the square range to take you to the next level. Personal Defense

Shooting Tips: Advanced Close Quarters AK Rifle Skills

John Peterson - May 13, 2020

Drills for beyond the square range to take you to the next level.

In Part 1 of this series we take you through how to prevent a carjacking from happening by using simple techniques to avoid it. Personal Defense

Carjacking Prevention — Top Things You Need To Know

John M. Peterson III - June 28, 2020

In Part 1 of this series we take you through how to prevent a carjacking from happening by...

The one guide you need for concealed carry gun law will soon be available in an updated second Personal Defense

Legally Armed CCW Guide

SGN Online Editors - May 11, 2015

The one guide you need for concealed carry gun law will soon be available in an updated second

See More Personal Defense

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW OUR CURRENT ISSUE

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Get Digital Access.

All Firearms News subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now