Open Carry Protests: Our Internal Dilemma

Open Carry Protests: Our Internal Dilemma
AP Photo

AP Photo

It's always dangerous to start writing about an issue by saying, "I feel strongly both ways," but that's how it is with the current controversy swirling around Open Carry Texas. OCT members have stirred up a hornet's nest by appearing at various fast-food eateries carrying rifles, with predictable outrage being generated in all the predictable places.

NRA waded in with a critique of the tactic as crossing "the line between enthusiasm and downright foolishness" and "downright weird." It then waded right back out again in the face of criticism from OCT and other Texas activists. That Texas two-step enabled the media to bash NRA twice: once for taking so long to be reasonable, and then again for backing away from reasonableness.

OCT president C.J. Grisham said the rifle-toting protests were intended to point out that open carry of rifles is authorized in Texas, while carrying pistols openly is not. That point proved too subtle by half, and OCT had already decided to quit appearing with long guns before the criticism from NRA.


Now a lot of OCT members are unhappy and cutting up their NRA cards, to the delight of the national media and anti-gunners everywhere. Discord inside the gun movement is something the antis pray for every day but rarely get to enjoy. Discord rarely lasts, and it never impairs the struggle for long, but you can't blame them for hoping.


It's very tempting to dismiss the open carriers as dangerous to the cause, because they often, as in the case of Starbucks, wind up forcing corporate leadership off the fence and into the other side's backyard. The publicity almost always looks bad, with lots of middle-aged white guys toting big, scary rifles where families and kids go. It's easy to say you support open carry in principle, while saying at the same time it should be done rarely, if ever.


The open-carry crowd can make the very valid contrary point that a whole variety of rights have been won through public actions that were regarded as outrageous at the time. The Alabama State Police certainly thought it was outrageous for protesters to try to cross the Edmund Pettus Bridge in 1965. They expressed that opinion with tear gas and nightsticks, leading directly to civil rights legislation that marked the end of Jim Crow.

The sight of two men holding hands or two women kissing was outrageous in the 1980s, but it you're outraged by it today, you better hold off watching the Tony Awards.

The Palestine Liberation Organization committed a long series of outrages like the simultaneous hijacking of three airliners in 1970, endless bombings and kidnappings, but it is no longer considered outrageous; right-thinking college professors these days loudly advocate boycotting Israel as an "apartheid state."


So an outrage, repeated often enough, can eventually become normal. What was an outrage becomes a right. Open-carry advocates think being loud and proud with our guns will ultimately make people less threatened and intimidated by them and make them learn to accept guns and their owners as a perfectly normal part of life.

I'll admit that seeing a crowd of open carriers crowding around a Sonic with AKs makes my teeth hurt. But at the same time, they're using a strategy that has proven to get results for other out-groups. We all agree on the goal: what are the right tactics? I feel strongly both ways.

Recommended for You

Hi-Point has YEETed its way to internet fame with the new YEET Cannon G1. Industry

New from Hi-Point: The YEET Cannon

David Fortier - July 18, 2019

Hi-Point has YEETed its way to internet fame with the new YEET Cannon G1.

We at 'Firearms News' hope that you have a safe and happy Independence Day! 2nd Amendment

It's Independence Day NOT Just the Fourth of July!

Firearms News Digital Staff

We at 'Firearms News' hope that you have a safe and happy Independence Day!

Sturm, Ruger & Company, Inc. introduced three models of the Ruger American Rimfire rifle with Go Wild Camo I-M Brush stock and bronze Cerakote finish. Rifles

Ruger American Rimfire with Go Wild Camo I-M Brush Stock

Ruger Firearms - July 10, 2019

Sturm, Ruger & Company, Inc. introduced three models of the Ruger American Rimfire rifle with...

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

The GPO Rangeguide 10x50

The GPO Rangeguide 10x50

If you need to see your game, and know the distance in all hunting environments, the GPO RANGEGUIDE 10×50 is your winning ticket.

Kyle Lamb and Eric Poole talk SIG pistols

Kyle Lamb and Eric Poole talk SIG pistols

G&A Editor Eric Poole and Viking Tacticals's Kyle Lamb talks about 2 new pistols from SIG Sauer and a Lipsey's Special of the P365.

New Bushnell Prime 1700 and Nitro 1800 Rangefinders

New Bushnell Prime 1700 and Nitro 1800 Rangefinders

Jake Edson of Bushnell Optics tells OSG's Lynn Burkhead about the brand new Prime 1700 and Nitro 1800 rangefinders.

See more Popular Videos

Trending Stories

The last of Germany's infamous Elefant tank destroyers. Historical

World War II German Elefant Tank Destroyers

Neal S Shera - July 12, 2019

The last of Germany's infamous Elefant tank destroyers.

A $50 Ring Loc-Kit gives AirForce Condor airgunners unparalleled power and accuracy. Air Guns

AirForce Airguns Condor Ring-Loc Kit Review

Tom Gaylord - May 29, 2019

A $50 Ring Loc-Kit gives AirForce Condor airgunners unparalleled power and accuracy.

CRKT makes 17 different knife models exclusively for Ruger, from fixed hunting knives to tactical folders, and many of their models are offered in several different styles. Accessories

Ruger CRKT Knives Review

James Tarr - July 08, 2019

CRKT makes 17 different knife models exclusively for Ruger, from fixed hunting knives to...

See More Stories

More 2nd Amendment

Unless the government gets back to basics on the Second Amendment, legal recognition of the right to keep and bear arms will be vulnerable to new edicts and court decisions supporting infringements. 2nd Amendment

Ignoring Core Purpose Makes 2nd Amendment More Vulnerable to Infringements: The Militia Aspect, Part 1

David Codrea - October 31, 2019

Unless the government gets back to basics on the Second Amendment, legal recognition of the...

In the wake of Walmart's recent anti-gun policy, it seems that denouncing lawful gun owners and the Second Amendment is currently in vogue. 2nd Amendment

145 CEOs Demand Senate 'Take Action' On Gun Control – One of Them Is the Brother of Trump's Senior Advisor

Jim Grant - September 12, 2019

In the wake of Walmart's recent anti-gun policy, it seems that denouncing lawful gun owners...

Florida State Representative Anthony Sabatini filed HB 273 last Tuesday, which would allow Floridians to carry concealed firearms for self-defense without a permit. 2nd Amendment

New Florida Bill 273 Allows Constitutional Carry

Jim Grant - October 04, 2019

Florida State Representative Anthony Sabatini filed HB 273 last Tuesday, which would allow...

See More 2nd Amendment

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Temporary Price Reduction.

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW OUR CURRENT ISSUE

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.