So You Want to Buy a Transferable Machine Gun?
January 07, 2015
There's nothing in the firearms world as fun and exciting as going full-auto. Unfortunately, there aren't a lot of transferable machine guns available on the market, and the process to acquire them seems daunting for many buyers.
Since the 1986 ban on registrations of new guns, the fixed supply has resulted in ever-increasing prices as collectors are less and less willing to part with their irreplaceable machine guns. Over the years, the transferable machine gun market has evolved into two separate markets: collectors and shooters. Decades ago, they used to be the same people.
For example, if I owned an original World War II German MP40 in 1965, I would not have much invested in the gun and wouldn't feel bad about taking it to the range on a rainy day, running a few thousand rounds of corrosive ammo through it, and neglecting to clean it for a few days.
The MP40 would have cost me $50 for the gun and $200 for the transfer tax (see flyer below). While $250 was a lot of money in 1965, nowadays an original MP40 may be worth $18,000 and up. Taking such a collectible gun to the range and running a few thousand rounds would not be a great idea because you'd be diminishing its value by adding wear, and possibly breaking, a 70 year-old part.
In many ways, buying a transferable machine gun is like buying a used car. You will typically be asking yourself the same questions:
- How many "miles" does it have?
- Was it severely damaged or "totaled" before?
- What parts look worn or broken and need to be replaced?
- Did the previous owners take care of it or was it neglected?
- Do I need a "mechanic" (gunsmith) to look it over before I commit to such a large purchase?
- Who can fix it when it breaks?
- Can I get spare parts?
- Am I being scammed? Sometimes you'll find people grossly misrepresenting the gun's condition or worse, offering a gun for sale they don't even possess.
For collectible guns (like an original MP40) just as with collectible cars, there are even more difficult questions to answer. Like any other collector's item, you are looking for the most collectible and authentic gun in the best condition. You'll want answers to the following questions:
- Is it authentic? Look for original parts, matching numbers, original finish, etc.
- Is it a (Deactivated War Trophy) DEWAT - (Reactivated War Trophy) REWAT? Many of the older collectible guns were sold as DEWATS because they were not subject to the $200 transfer tax. (In 1965, $200 would be equivalent to nearly $1400 today.) Many of the DEWAT guns have been REWAT and sold as live guns.
- Does it work? Some guns are so old that the current owners won't shoot them or don't care to.
- Is the seller accurately representing the gun? Sometimes an honest seller just doesn't know or can't tell. He may be the tenth owner. Some of these old guns are confusing to the experts as well. For example, if he bought an MP40 in 2000 from another collector who bought it in 1990, and the gun was REWAT (reactivated) by a previous owner in the 1980s, then transferred on a Form 4, there's no accessible paper trail showing that the gun is a DEWAT-REWAT. Since these transfers are considered private tax information by ATF, they will not divulge data of previous transfers.
My best advice for those looking to buy collectible guns is to go to the major shows and get to know the dealers who typically sell them and the other collectors who already own them. You'll find that the easiest people to talk to will also be the easiest people to deal with in the future.
Read as many detailed books on the guns you are interested in as possible and become an expert yourself. Peter Kokalis' Shotgun News feature articles, and Collector Grade Publications are great resources.
Once you've done the research and know what you are looking at, you should lay eyes on the gun you want to buy and take some time to examine it. Don't forget the white gloves.
Those of us more interested in moving lead are primarily concerned with performance, durability, and ease of service. You'll need to decide what you want out of the full-auto experience and the gun that will best fit your budget and capabilities. There are seven basic categories of machine guns:
- Submachine Gun (SMG): pistol caliber/full-auto, e.g. MP40, MP5, Thompson, M11, Stemple Takedown Gun
- Assault Rifle: intermediate caliber/select-fire: e.g. M16, AK47, FNC, AC556
- Battle Rifle: rifle caliber/select-fire: e.g. M14, FAL, G3
- Light Machine Gun (LMG): rifle or intermediate caliber/full-auto/bipod mounted: e.g. Lewis, BAR, SAW
- General Purpose Machineguns (GPMG): rifle caliber/full-auto/bipod or tripod mounted: e.g. MG34, MG42, M60
- Medium Machine Gun (MMG): rifle caliber/full-auto/tripod mounted: e.g. Browning 1917, Vickers MMG, Russian 1910 Maxim
- Heavy Machine Gun (HMG): large caliber/full-auto/tripod mounted: e.g. Browning M2HB 50 cal.
Everyone has his own opinion of what's enjoyable to shoot. Some people like the fast "squirt" of an M11 with a "MacJack" or a mag dump through a short and light 308 like an HK51. For me, what makes full-auto shooting fun is the nexus of capacity and control. If I can hold down the trigger and draw long straight lines on the backstop, I have a fun-to-shoot machine gun.
The bigger the gun, the more parts you'll have to worry about breaking and the more you'll have to be a "mechanic" to keep it running. Once you get up to LMG-sized guns, stockpiling parts becomes a necessity. If you can't make or buy parts to keep your gun running well, you'll have a transferable full-auto paperweight after a few outings. Buying an LMG or HMG for shooting is a huge commitment in time and money.
For the guns smaller than LMGs, many on the market are simply rifles with a full-auto capability. They are generally not good for sustained full-auto firing. When I consider a machine gun, I ask this question: Can I fire 500 rounds in five minutes without breaking the gun?
For me, the best machine guns on the transferable market are belt-fed guns on tripods (preferably water-cooled) and SMGs with high capacity drums. My personal favorites to shoot are the Stemple 76/45 U9 setup (9mm, 70-round drum, 13-inch barrel, 4X scope, bipod), and a Vickers MMG (.303 British, 200-round belt, tripod-mounted, water-cooled).
Sometimes the idea of a shooting a gun is not as good as the actual experience. Determine what you like by getting some trigger time on a variety of full-auto guns. Spend some time at rental ranges and organized events like the Knob Creek machine gun shoot.
Become a technical expert on the specific gun you want. Educate yourself on market for the specific gun, spare parts, and service options you may need. Get to know other shooters who own similar guns. The machine gun community is very welcoming and you'll meet some great people. Acquiring the right full-auto gun for you will be a worthwhile and enjoyable investment.
(Brian Poling is President of BRP Corp., a company that has been in the business of manufacturing and importing machine guns since 1999. It specializes in historic World War II machine guns and the Stemple 76/45 submachine gun in conjunction with JR Stemple & Co Arms LLC.)