Skip to main content

The 9mm vs. 40S&W: Which is Better?

Should you choose a .40 S&W over a 9mm Parabellum? Here are a few thoughts on the mid-bore pistol cartridge.

The 9mm vs. 40S&W: Which is Better?

Should you consider buying a handgun chambered in .40 S&W today? Michelle Hamilton shares her thoughts on the short .40 caliber. (Patrick Sweeney photo)

The .40 caliber was an answer to a question that was quickly answered, and the answer is not .40 S&W. Plain and simple. Modern projectile technology solved a lot of issues formerly experienced with older duty caliber handgun loads, and has improved terminal performance overall. Once ammunition manufacturers started understanding the basic formula for designing reliable expanding handgun bullets, the caliber debate among duty calibers ultimately died.

Considering the studies and work of wound ballistics from Dr. Martin Fackler, the International Wound Ballistic Association and the FBI, ammunition companies began focusing more on weight retention, controlled expansion and delivering the most weight to vital organs, which means optimal penetration. In accordance with the FBI, "12-18 inches of penetration" is optimal performance for handgun projectiles. This is the criteria that most credible ammunition companies design their defensive ammunition to today.

.40 S&W cartridge
The .40 S&W cartridge was designed by Bob Klunk in a joint venture between Smith & Wesson and Winchester and introduced in 1990. It was intended to offer a larger and heavier projectile over the 9mm Parabellum and a higher magazine capacity compared to the .45 ACP. (James Walters photo)

When the .40 S&W and .357 SIG were introduced, consistent performing 9mm Parabellum options were really few and far between. Even Winchesters SXT/Black Talon (what I often call, the "grandfather of modern bullet performance") was still in its infancy. Many poor performers existed on the market. The infamous "Silvertip" 115-grain from Winchester (see Miami 1986 shootout) and Federal Hi-Shok 115-grain were among some common ammunition offerings at this time. Both cartridges were considered poor performers in roughly every aspect, especially in terms of FBI protocol. The .40 S&W gave a larger diameter projectile compared to the 9mm Parabellum and higher magazine capacity and velocity over the .45 ACP. It also provided lower felt recoil than the 10mm Auto. At this time, the .40 S&W and .357 SIG both seemed like a good fit for defensive use.

While it is true that surface area delivered to vital organs can provide more disruption of vitals, it is also true the 9mm Parabellum’s velocity advantage provides consistently higher velocities, meaning the 9mm has a higher probability of consistent expansion when interacting in various densities and light barriers (such as heavy clothing, an FBI test protocol). This, coupled with modern ammunition capabilities and performance, means duty calibers are on a practically even playing field (with slight advantages and disadvantages between calibers) when it comes to terminal performance.

.40 S&W cartridge
Modern expanding 9mm Parabellum projectiles, like this 115-grain TAC-XP solid copper HP from Black Hills Ammunition, provide reliable expansion and penetration on par with .40 S&W loads. (Photo courtesy of Black Hills Ammunition)

Basically, modern expanding 9mm projectile designs provide reliable expansion and the desired level of penetration. The result is terminal performance on par with similar modern .40 S&W loads. In addition though, in similar size and weight firearms, the 9mm Parabellum will exhibit less felt recoil. This makes for a more comfortable and easier to shoot handgun, and reduced split times between shots. The 9mm Parabellum also holds an advantage when it comes to magazine capacity over the .40 S&W. So, today the 9mm Parabellum has on par terminal performance, less felt recoil and holds more cartridges in a similar-size platform compared to mid-bore .40 S&W.

In the end, caliber should be the least of a user’s concern. Shot placement, recoil mitigation, shot consistency, capacity, ability and training should be higher on a user’s list. Is the .40 S&W dead? Not really. It is a caliber designed to fix a problem that technology ultimately fixed. If it wasn’t for Police Departments and Government agencies jumping on the .40 caliber bandwagon back in the day, it would likely be a more obscure caliber today, like the .41 Magnum. So, if given the option I’d pick a 9mm Parabellum over a .40 S&W today.

If you have any thoughts or comments on this article, we’d love to hear them. Email us at FirearmsNews@Outdoorsg.com.

About the Author:

Michelle Hamilton has a Bachelor’s degree in Criminal Justice/Homeland Security, is a serious student of military history, small arms design and manufacturing and is a competitive shooter.




GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

Recent Videos

Firearms News Editor-in-Chief Vince DeNiro learns what sets Federal's “Punch” line of ammunition apart from the hollow p...
Guns

Hydra Weaponry Brings the Bushmaster Arm Pistol Back to Life

Firearms News Editor-in-Chief Vince DeNiro learns what sets Federal's “Punch” line of ammunition apart from the hollow p...
Gear

Hornady's 245gr Interlock Takes Straight-Wall Cartridges to New Level

Firearms News Editor-in-Chief Vince DeNiro learns what sets Federal's “Punch” line of ammunition apart from the hollow p...
Gear

Rise Armament Releases New RA-100 Two-Stage Trigger for AR-15s

Firearms News Editor-in-Chief Vince DeNiro learns what sets Federal's “Punch” line of ammunition apart from the hollow p...
Gear

Silencer Central's New Banish 9K Pistol Suppressor

Firearms News Editor-in-Chief Vince DeNiro learns what sets Federal's “Punch” line of ammunition apart from the hollow p...
Gear

Shinenyx Announces New Series of Weapon-Mounted Thermal Optic Packed with Exciting Features

Firearms News Editor-in-Chief Vince DeNiro learns what sets Federal's “Punch” line of ammunition apart from the hollow p...
Gear

New Pulsar Merger LRF XT50 Thermal Binocular

Firearms News Editor-in-Chief Vince DeNiro learns what sets Federal's “Punch” line of ammunition apart from the hollow p...
Guns

Luth-AR Offering New In-House Barrels for AR-15s

Firearms News Editor-in-Chief Vince DeNiro learns what sets Federal's “Punch” line of ammunition apart from the hollow p...
Guns

Aero Precision M4E1 Pro Rifle

Firearms News Editor-in-Chief Vince DeNiro learns what sets Federal's “Punch” line of ammunition apart from the hollow p...
Guns

Dr. Dabbs Goes Ape! A Video Review of the Gorilla M1 Carbine from the Original Planet of the Apes!

Firearms News Editor-in-Chief Vince DeNiro learns what sets Federal's “Punch” line of ammunition apart from the hollow p...
Guns

Pioneer Arms .22 LR Trainer AK Rifle

Firearms News Editor-in-Chief Vince DeNiro learns what sets Federal's “Punch” line of ammunition apart from the hollow p...
Guns

Pioneer Arms GROM 7.62x39 AK Rifle

Firearms News Editor-in-Chief Vince DeNiro learns what sets Federal's “Punch” line of ammunition apart from the hollow p...
Gear

Federal's “Punch” line of Personal Protection Ammunition

Firearms News Magazine Covers Print and Tablet Versions

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW OUR CURRENT ISSUE

Buy Digital Single Issues

Magazine App Logo

Don't miss an issue.
Buy single digital issue for your phone or tablet.

Get the Firearms News App apple store google play store

Other Magazines

See All Other Magazines

Special Interest Magazines

See All Special Interest Magazines

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Get the top Firearms News stories delivered right to your inbox.

Phone Icon

Get Digital Access.

All Firearms News subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now

Enjoying What You're Reading?

Get a Full Year
of Guns & Ammo
& Digital Access.

Offer only for new subscribers.

Subscribe Now

Never Miss a Thing.

Get the Newsletter

Get the top Firearms News stories delivered right to your inbox.

By signing up, I acknowledge that my email address is valid, and have read and accept the Terms of Use