California Judge Questions AR-15 Lower ATF Classification

California Judge Questions AR-15 Lower ATF Classification
Photo source: DreamsTime.com

California District Court Judge James V. Selena recently questioned the validity of the ATF’s classification of AR15 lowers as firearms during a recent criminal case. The case in question involved an individual that was hosting build parties where individuals would take 80% AR receivers, place them in a CNC machine and press a button to complete remaining cuts to meet the ATF’s classification as a firearm.

By requiring builders to press the button on the machine, the defendant reasoned that he wasn’t operating as a manufacturer - the ATF saw things differently though.

Judge Selena determined that since the lower isn’t threaded for a barrel and doesn’t contain the bolt or breechblock, it doesn’t meet the legal definition of a firearm as set forth in 27 C.F.R. § 478.11. This runs contrary to the ATF’s interpretation of the law, and interestingly enough, prosecutors actively sought to prevent this interpretation from setting a precedent.

Which seems counter-intuitive, given the propensity of CA prosecutors and politicians to jump on any gun confiscation bandwagon possible. According to the reports of the case, the deal was struck because a sudden reclassification of the law would severely frustrate enforcement of existing gun laws.



Which makes sense. Imagine if tomorrow none of your lowers were considered firearms, but all your uppers were. Millions of Americans could instantly become felons in possession of countless firearms which were not registered by licensed manufacturers, while simultaneously owning registered lowers that are no longer considered firearms. In a nutshell, their records would be stuffed with bad data, and there would be more unregistered guns in American than ever before. A prospect that is truly terrifying to Democratic politicians and wet blankets everywhere. 

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Springfield Armory Saint Victor in .308

Springfield Armory Saint Victor in .308

The Saint Victor in .308 features a 16" light weight barrel, M-Lok® free float hand guard and included flip-up sights.

The GPO Rangeguide 10x50

The GPO Rangeguide 10x50

If you need to see your game, and know the distance in all hunting environments, the GPO RANGEGUIDE 10×50 is your winning ticket.

M134 Mini-Gun

M134 Mini-Gun

While filming the 2018 season of Guns&AmmoTV we had the unique opportunity to fire the M134 Minigun.

Kyle Lamb and Eric Poole talk SIG pistols

Kyle Lamb and Eric Poole talk SIG pistols

G&A Editor Eric Poole and Viking Tacticals's Kyle Lamb talks about 2 new pistols from SIG Sauer and a Lipsey's Special of the P365.

See More Popular Videos

Trending Articles

If you want to keep the peace, keep and bear arms. Don't give up your guns. Any other choice would be ridiculous. 2nd Amendment

Is Red Dawn Really Just Ridiculous? If Not, Who Would Citizen Disarmament Help?

David Codrea - May 29, 2019

If you want to keep the peace, keep and bear arms. Don't give up your guns. Any other choice...

No one can restore receptivity to another Trump term with these disaffected gun owners but the president himself. 2nd Amendment

2020 is Trump's to Blow with Gun Owners

David Codrea - July 09, 2019

No one can restore receptivity to another Trump term with these disaffected gun owners but the...

CRKT makes 17 different knife models exclusively for Ruger, from fixed hunting knives to tactical folders, and many of their models are offered in several different styles. Accessories

Ruger CRKT Knives Review

James Tarr - July 08, 2019

CRKT makes 17 different knife models exclusively for Ruger, from fixed hunting knives to...

Want the “Holy Grail” of AR-15 rifles? Brownells has made that possible with their BRN-Proto retro rifle. Rifles

Brownells BRN-Proto Retro Rifle

Patrick Sweeney - July 02, 2019

Want the “Holy Grail” of AR-15 rifles? Brownells has made that possible with their BRN-Proto...

See More Trending Articles

More 2nd Amendment

Depending on what happens next November, we're likely to see more ripping asunder of the national fabric. 2nd Amendment

Ignoring Core Purpose Makes 2nd Amendment More Vulnerable to Infringements: The Militia Aspect, Part 2

David Codrea - February 11, 2020

Depending on what happens next November, we're likely to see more ripping asunder of the...

Ever Heard of the “Movie Gun Transfer” Form? 2nd Amendment

Think You Know All About NFA Forms?

Vincent DeNiro, Editor - March 23, 2020

Ever Heard of the “Movie Gun Transfer” Form?

The U.S. lodging company pledged $300,000 to Canadian Doctors for Protection From Guns, which lobbies the government to ban guns from the country's 2.2 million adults with a federal firearm licence. 2nd Amendment

Airbnb Financing Group Campaigning Against Canadian Gun Owners

TheGunBlog.ca - February 19, 2020

The U.S. lodging company pledged $300,000 to Canadian Doctors for Protection From Guns, which...

Reuters Reports That the NRA Is Willing to Compromise (Yet Again) on the 2nd Amendment 2nd Amendment

NRA 2A Compromise

Firearms News Staff Report - January 21, 2020

Reuters Reports That the NRA Is Willing to Compromise (Yet Again) on the 2nd Amendment

See More 2nd Amendment

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW OUR CURRENT ISSUE

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.